top of page

Be Kind, Not Just Nice: Navigating Difficult Holiday Conversations Around the Family Table

Dec 10, 2025
4 min read

Breaking the Tyranny of Polite Silence

With the holiday season comes the warmth of shared meals, family reunions, and festive gatherings across Greater Pinellas. For many LGBTQ+ individuals and the people who love them, however, holiday invitations also carry a familiar knot of stomach-churning anxiety. What do you do when a relative drops an anti-trans talking point between bites of green bean casserole? What do you say when someone questions your child's pronouns over pie?

Too often, especially in Southern and Midwestern families, we are taught to prioritize being nice over everything else. We smile politely, swallow our discomfort, and stare down at our plates to avoid making a scene. But being nice is often just passive conflict avoidance that leaves our most vulnerable family members out in the cold.

Being kind, by contrast, requires courageous, protective action. Kindness means intervening when harm occurs, setting firm boundaries, and defending human dignity, all while keeping your own nervous system steady. At PFLAG Safety Harbor / Greater Pinellas, we believe in giving families the tools to move from anxious silence to loving clarity.


Playing the Devil's Advocate and the Art of the Strategic Pause

We have all met the self-appointed devil's advocate. Back in the late 2010s, I remember listening to a sister-in-law repeatedly introduce hostile political opinions under the polite banner of "just playing devil's advocate." It took me a while to realize something simple: the devil already has plenty of lawyers, and defending arguments that actively strip away the rights of marginalized people is not harmless intellectual sparring.

Over the years, I developed a simple, kind method for handling bad-faith remarks: play gently curious. When someone drops an offensive comment or dog whistle, I do not fly off the handle. I ask them, with a warm face and calm voice, "I'm sorry, what did you say?"

Asking someone to repeat an ugly comment out loud often stops them in their tracks. If they do repeat it, follow up with genuine curiosity: "What do you mean by that?" That gives them the benefit of the doubt, just in case they spoke clumsily without malicious intent. But if they meant exactly what they said, let the words hang in the room. Sitting in two seconds of calm silence sends a clearer message than a shouting match: you really just said that out loud.


The Ouch and Educate Conversational Model

Confronting hurtful comments does not require throwing dishes or burning family bridges. One of PFLAG National's most practical communication tools is the Ouch and Educate model, drawn from the Straight for Equality program:

Start with the immediate verbal pause: say "Ouch." A gentle "Ouch, that hurts to hear" interrupts the social flow and signals that a boundary was crossed without putting everyone on defensive alert.

Follow with an invitation to learn. Shift from accusation to personal connection: "That hasn't been our family's experience at all. Can I share what we have learned since our child came out?"

Set the firm boundary if they double down. If the conversation turns hostile, be clear and unwavering: "We love having family dinner together, but in this home, we treat people with dignity. We are not going to debate our child's basic humanity at this table."

For video demonstrations of these conversational shifts, check out the national PFLAG workshops Be Kind, Not Just Nice: Transforming Your Conversation and Be Kind Rewind: Recognizing Your Role in Building Inclusion.


Radical Hospitality and Chosen Kin in Pinellas County

Sometimes, biological family gatherings are simply not safe or affirming, no matter how skilled you are at de-escalation. Walking away from persistent hostility is not failure; it is self-preservation. When biological tables feel cold, our chosen family is ready to pull up an extra chair.

We are deeply grateful for community partners like Allendale United Methodist Church in St. Petersburg, where Pastor Andy Oliver and the congregation put radical hospitality into action every week. Whether it is an inclusive community meal or a welcoming Sunday gathering, knowing there are places where you are cherished without reservation makes all the difference.


Bringing Kindness to the Field and the Table

Whether I am out on the dusty kickball field in St. Pete with our HotMess Sports crew or sitting with families at our Safety Harbor support circles, I have learned that kindness and a silly, grounded spirit are our best tools. As I wrote in my poem Not Too Much: "They called it extra. I called it holy... Don't call it 'too much' just because it won't fit inside your jar."

Before you head into holiday gatherings this season, download PFLAG National's comprehensive guide, the Straight for Equality: Guide to Being an LGBTQ+ Ally. Establish your boundaries, agree on an exit strategy with your loved ones, and remember that leading with love starts by protecting the people in your care.



Resource Update (October 2026): Post updated by Adam Ryan to incorporate national Straight for Equality video links and active de-escalation frameworks.

Comments


pflag-safety-harbor-greater-pinellas-logo-white.png

"Leading With Love"

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

© 2026 by PFLAG Safety Harbor / Greater Pinellas.

Need Immediate Support?

The Trevor Project

Call 1-866-488-7386 or text START to 678-678

Trans Lifeline

1-877-565-8860 | Crisis & Suicide Lifeline: Call/Text 988

PFLAG Safety Harbor / Greater Pinellas is a registered 501(c)(3) tax-exempt nonprofit organization. Contributions are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.

​

Florida Registration Disclosure: A copy of the official registration and financial information may be obtained from the Florida Division of Consumer Services by calling toll-free (1-800-435-7352) within the state or visiting www.FloridaConsumerHelp.com. Registration does not imply endorsement, approval, or recommendation by the state.

​

Peer Support Notice: Our circles and guides provide interpersonal support and family education, not clinical therapy or medical assessment.

Stay Connected With PFLAG Safety Harbor & Greater Pinellas! Sign up for our community newsletter for event updates, family support circles, and local advocacy alerts.

bottom of page